As I wrote in this blog post too many Catholics put their faith in a particular political party before their Catholic faith.
While I believe that our faith should inform our political choices, politics should not inform our faith. In the increasingly divided country that we live in, Christians are too often influenced by the tribal party that they identify with instead of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
Consequently people who are Pro Life defend politicians and parties that are decidedly pro abortion. Other people who are, also, Pro life, play mental Twister to defend politicians who advocate torture.
Yes the Church does encourage us to vote. Sometimes the only choice is none of the above.
Catholics are not one more “interest group” which can be polled, pandered to and bought. Our social obligation is to promote the true common good, not just use the slogan to sound “catholic” as happened in the last political cycle. We need to promote the truth as taught by the Church no matter what it is labeled in the political parlance of the hour. Our political participation must be committed to human life and dignity, marriage and the family, authentic human freedom, and solidarity.
Well I identify as simply Catholic. I am a political agnostic. My participation in the public square is, for the most part, limited to voting while holding my nose. But I am an informed observer of the political scene.
Deacon Fournier’s call for Catholics to be morally coherent or consistent is a wise and noble one. But moral consistency and/or intellectual consistency is just not very common. Consistency requires logical reasoning. When our moral beliefs are based on sentiment and feelings, the only outcome is moral relativism. Moral relativism is inconsistent. It is the doctrine of whatever.
That is why we have people who think that it is okay to be for abortion “choice” and against the death penalty; and why we have those who think that it is compatible to be pro-life and for torture. Me thinks that we have a long way to go before anyone, including Catholics, strive for coherence moral or otherwise.